Providence

The Doctrine of God’s Providence — A Position Paper

Bruce Mitchell

❖   ❖   ❖

A Brief Statement

I hold that providence is God’s continual, sovereign, and gracious governance of all that He has made. Having created the world, He did not abandon it to itself or to chance; He upholds every creature in being, cooperates in all that it does, and directs all things — great and small — to the ends He has appointed. Nothing happens outside His will, and nothing happens by accident.

He ordains whatsoever comes to pass, yet in such a way that He is never the author of sin and never destroys the genuine agency and accountability of His creatures. He permits evil and bends it to serve His good purposes; He cares with a Father’s tenderness for His own; and He works all things together for the good of those who love Him — to the praise of the glory of His name.

❖   ❖   ❖

A Detailed Exposition

What Providence Is

When we confess that God is the Maker of heaven and earth, we have not yet said all that must be said, for He is also its Ruler and its Sustainer. Providence is the name for that continuing work. The word comes from the Latin providentia, “foresight” or “provision,” and answers the Greek pronoia; the older theologians analyzed it into three parts: God preserves what He has made, cooperates in all that it does, and governs it toward His appointed ends.¹ This sets the Christian doctrine apart at once from the deism that pictures God as a watchmaker who wound up the world and walked away. The God of Scripture has not retired. He is at work in the falling of every raindrop and the rising of every empire — never idle, never absent, never surprised.

Preservation

First, God preserves. The creation is not self-sustaining; it hangs upon Him moment by moment. The Son “upholds the universe by the word of His power” (Hebrews 1:3), and “in Him all things hold together” (Colossians 1:17); “in Him we live and move and have our being” (Acts 17:28). Were God to withdraw His sustaining hand for an instant, the whole frame of things would lapse into nothing. That the sun rose this morning and our hearts have gone on beating is not the working of an autonomous machine but the faithfulness of a present God.²

Concurrence

Second, God cooperates with what He preserves. This is what the theologians call concurrence — God’s working in, with, and through the things He has made and the choices His creatures make, without coercing them or canceling their reality. The same event may be, in one respect, wholly God’s work and, in another, wholly the creature’s: God gives the harvest, yet the farmer plows and the rain falls; “the lot is cast into the lap, but its every decision is from the LORD” (Proverbs 16:33); “the king’s heart is a stream of water in the hand of the LORD” (Proverbs 21:1). God does not usually bypass means; He works through them — so really that the means are genuine, and so sovereignly that the outcome is sure.³

Government

Third, God governs. He directs all that He preserves and concurs with toward the ends He has set — over nature, over the nations, and over each individual life. “His kingdom rules over all” (Psalm 103:19); He “does according to His will among the host of heaven and among the inhabitants of the earth, and none can stay His hand” (Daniel 4:35). His reach is not only to the grand sweep of history but to its smallest particulars: not a sparrow falls to the ground apart from Him, and the very hairs of our heads are numbered (Matthew 10:29–30). He “works all things according to the counsel of His will” (Ephesians 1:11) — all things, and according to a settled plan.⁴

Sovereignty and Human Responsibility

At once, the great question presses: if God governs all things, what becomes of human freedom and human responsibility? Scripture does not flinch from teaching both. It affirms, on the one hand, that God ordains whatsoever comes to pass; and, on the other, that men choose, act, and answer for what they do. The Westminster divines stated the balance about as well as it can be stated: God has ordained whatsoever comes to pass, “yet so as thereby neither is God the author of sin, nor is violence offered to the will of the creatures.”⁵ I hold these two truths together, as Scripture does, without pretending to dissolve the mystery where they meet. And the balance must be guarded on both sides. It is not fatalism, which makes us puppets of blind necessity and denies that our choices are real; biblical sovereignty establishes responsibility rather than erasing it. Nor will it permit the modern “open theism” that secures human freedom by denying God’s exhaustive knowledge and ordination of the future — for the God of Scripture declares “the end from the beginning” (Isaiah 46:10) and knows our words before they are on our tongue (Psalm 139:4).⁶

Providence and Evil

No part of this doctrine is harder or more important than the relation of a holy God to a world full of evil. Scripture’s answer is neither that evil lies outside His control nor that He is its author, but that He permits it, restrains it, and overrules it — bending even the worst of it to serve His good and wise ends, while remaining Himself untouched by its guilt. Joseph said it for all his brothers had done: “You meant evil against me, but God meant it for good” (Genesis 50:20) — one deed, two designs, theirs wicked and His good. And the cross stands as the supreme case: Christ was “delivered up according to the definite plan and foreknowledge of God,” and, in the same breath, “you crucified and killed [Him] by the hands of lawless men” (Acts 2:23; cf. 4:27–28). The worst act in all of history was at that very moment the saving plan of God — yet the hands that did it were fully guilty. God ordained the act for a holy end; the men willed it for an evil one; and the guilt was theirs alone.⁷

Ordinary and Extraordinary Providence

God ordinarily works through means — the steady laws of nature, the labors and decisions of people — and we should expect to find Him there, in the ordinary, far more often than in the spectacular. Yet He is not bound by His ordinary ways; He remains free to work above or beyond means in a miracle when it pleases Him. And because He has ordained the means as surely as the ends, His providence is no argument against prayer or effort but the very ground of them. Elijah “prayed fervently that it might not rain … then he prayed again, and the heavens gave rain” (James 5:17–18); and we are told to “work out” our salvation for the very reason that “it is God who works in [us]” (Philippians 2:12–13). To believe in providence is not to fold our hands but to pray, to labor, and to leave the outcome with God.⁸

Special Providence: The Care of God for His People

Overall, in His works, God exercises a general government; but over His own redeemed, He keeps a special, fatherly watch. “And we know that for those who love God all things work together for good, for those who are called according to His purpose” (Romans 8:28). The promise is not that all things are good — many are bitter — but that God works them together for good, and the “good” He has in view is named in the next verse: to be conformed to the image of His Son (Romans 8:29). On this the security of the believer rests. The same providence that governs the stars governs the trials of His children, so that nothing “will be able to separate us from the love of God in Christ Jesus our Lord” (Romans 8:38–39).⁹ What befalls the Christian is not fate, and not luck, but the wise and loving appointment of his Father.

❖   ❖   ❖

Practical Implications

Ministry Emphasis: Trust in Suffering and Daily Life

First, providence is the soft pillow on which a weary believer lays his head. If nothing can touch me but through my Father’s hand, then nothing that touches me is meaningless or out of control. The old catechism captured the comfort exactly: that all things come to us “not by chance, but from His fatherly hand,” so that we may be patient in adversity, thankful in prosperity, and, for the future, confident in our faithful God. To know providence is to be able to sleep at night.

Second, it is the cure for anxiety and the death of our illusions of control. Our Lord pointed to the birds, who neither sow nor reap, and to the lilies, who neither toil nor spin, and asked why we who are worth so much more should be afraid (Matthew 6:25–34). Because a sovereign Father governs all, we may “cast all [our] anxieties on Him, because He cares for [us]” (1 Peter 5:7). The worrier and the control-seeker are alike trying to carry a weight that belongs to God.

Third — and this lies near my heart — providence is a word of hope for the broken that does not deny their pain. To the man wrecked by what others have done to him, or by what he has done, the doctrine does not say that the evil was good; it says that God is greater than the evil and can weave even this into good. The pit Joseph’s brothers dug became the road to a throne and the saving of many lives. I would minister to hurting men in just this confidence: the wreckage is real, but it is not the end of the story, and it is never outside the hand of God.

Finally, providence is no excuse for idleness or fatalism. Because God ordains means and not only ends, the right response to His sovereignty is not “whatever will be, will be,” but prayer, labor, and obedience — doing our duty and trusting Him with the result. And through it all the aim is His glory; for the God who upholds, accompanies, and governs all things does so that in everything He might be honored — “to Him be glory forever” (Romans 11:36).

Nothing by chance, nothing outside His hand — a sovereign Father governing all things, and bending even evil to good.

❖   ❖   ❖

Biblical, Exegetical, Theological, and Historical Notes

1. “Providence” comes from the Latin providentia (from providere, “to foresee, to provide”), answering the Greek pronoia (πρόνοια), “forethought.” Theologically, it denotes God’s continued work of upholding and governing all that He has made. The Reformed dogmaticians distinguished three aspects: preservation (conservatio), concurrence or cooperation (concursus), and government (gubernatio). Providence is to be sharply distinguished from the deism that imagines God set the world in motion and then withdrew from it.
2. God not only made the world but also continually sustains it in being. The Son “upholds the universe by the word of His power” — pherōn (φέρων), “carrying” it along (Hebrews 1:3) — and “in Him all things hold together” (synistēmi, συνίστημι; Colossians 1:17). “In Him we live and move and have our being” (Acts 17:28); “You give life to all of them” (Nehemiah 9:6). Creation is not a self-winding clock but a continual gift.
3. Concurrence (the divine concursus) is God’s working in, with, and through secondary causes — natural processes and the free acts of creatures — without coercing or destroying them. The same event is, in different respects, wholly the work of God (as first cause) and wholly the work of the creature (as second cause): God sends the rain (Matthew 5:45; Acts 14:17), yet the clouds and seasons do their work; “the lot is cast into the lap, but its every decision is from the LORD” (Proverbs 16:33); “the king’s heart is a stream of water in the hand of the LORD” (Proverbs 21:1).
4. By government, God directs all things to the ends He has appointed — over nature, over the nations, and over individuals. “His kingdom rules over all” (Psalm 103:19); He “does according to His will among the host of heaven and among the inhabitants of the earth” (Daniel 4:35); not a sparrow falls, nor a hair of our heads, apart from Him (Matthew 10:29–30). He “works all things according to the counsel (boulē, βουλή) of His will” (Ephesians 1:11).
5. Scripture teaches both that God ordains whatsoever comes to pass and that man acts freely and is genuinely responsible. The Westminster Confession states it carefully: God “did … ordain whatsoever comes to pass; yet so as thereby neither is God the author of sin, nor is violence offered to the will of the creatures” (3.1; cf. 5.4). The two truths are held together as a compatibility our minds cannot fully resolve, yet Scripture asserts both without embarrassment (Genesis 50:20; Acts 2:23; Philippians 2:12–13).
6. Two errors stand opposed to this. Fatalism makes events the product of blind necessity and denies real human agency; the biblical doctrine, by contrast, establishes responsibility rather than abolishing it. Open theism, at the other extreme, preserves human freedom by denying that God exhaustively foreknows or ordains future free acts — a denial Scripture will not allow, for God declares “the end from the beginning” (Isaiah 46:9–10) and knows our words before we speak them (Psalm 139:4). The Arminian, it should be said, affirms God’s exhaustive foreknowledge while grounding it differently than the Reformed; open theism, however, falls outside the bounds of historic orthodoxy. I hold the Reformed view (see my paper on Soteriology), while honoring Arminian brethren who confess the same all-knowing God.
7. How a holy God governs a world with evil in it is the hardest question in the doctrine. Scripture’s answer is that God permits, restrains, and overrules evil, bending it to good ends without Himself doing or approving evil. Joseph said it for all: “You meant evil against me, but God meant it for good” (Genesis 50:20) — one act, two intentions, the brothers’ wicked and God’s good. The supreme instance is the cross: Christ was “delivered up according to the definite plan and foreknowledge of God,” and yet “you crucified and killed [Him] by the hands of lawless men” (Acts 2:23; cf. 4:27–28). God ordains the act for a holy end; the creature wills it for an evil one; and the guilt is the creature’s. This is the heart of any sound theodicy: God’s sovereignty over evil never makes Him its author.
8. God ordinarily works through means — the laws of nature, the labors and choices of people — yet He is free to work above or beyond them in a miracle. Because He ordains means as truly as ends, providence is no argument against prayer or effort but the very ground of them: Elijah “prayed fervently that it might not rain, and … prayed again, and the heaven gave rain” (James 5:17–18), and we “work out” our salvation precisely because “it is God who works in [us], both to will and to work for His good pleasure” (Philippians 2:12–13). To trust providence is not to sit still but to pray and to labor, leaving the outcome to God.
9. Beyond His general government of all things, God exercises a special, fatherly care over His redeemed. “And we know that for those who love God all things work together for good” (Romans 8:28); the verb synergei (συνεργεῖ) means not that all things are good, but that God works them together for good — the “good” being defined in the next verse as conformity to the image of His Son (8:29). On this rests the believer’s security: nothing “will be able to separate us from the love of God in Christ Jesus” (Romans 8:38–39). See my paper on Eternal Security.

❖   ❖   ❖

Select Bibliography

Bavinck, Herman. Reformed Dogmatics. Vol. 2, God and Creation. Grand Rapids: Baker Academic.

Berkhof, Louis. Systematic Theology. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans.

Calvin, John. Institutes of the Christian Religion. Book I. Philadelphia: Westminster.

Carson, D. A. How Long, O Lord? Reflections on Suffering and Evil. Grand Rapids: Baker.

Chafer, Lewis Sperry. Systematic Theology. Dallas: Dallas Seminary Press.

Flavel, John. The Mystery of Providence. Edinburgh: Banner of Truth.

Frame, John M. The Doctrine of God. Phillipsburg, N.J.: P&R.

The Heidelberg Catechism (1563).

Helm, Paul. The Providence of God. Downers Grove: InterVarsity Press.

Ryrie, Charles C. Basic Theology. Wheaton: Victor Books.

Sproul, R. C. The Invisible Hand: Do All Things Really Work for Good? Grand Rapids: Baker.

The Westminster Confession of Faith (1646), chapters 3 and 5.