Most of us learned to share the gospel from a few well-worn New Testament verses, and God has used them to bring many people home. Paul walked into the synagogue at Thessalonica with none of them. His letters weren’t written yet. All he carried were the Scriptures his listeners already loved: the Law, the Prophets, and the Writings. For three Sabbaths he opened those scrolls and showed that the Messiah had to suffer and rise from the dead. Only then did he say the name: this Jesus is the Messiah. This study walks the road Paul walked, from the promise in Eden to David’s throne, Isaiah’s suffering Servant, the cry of Psalm 22, and the visions of Daniel. Set your New Testament aside for a little while and come along. By the end, you’ll have the portrait in front of you, and you’ll know who fits it.
Could You Prove Jesus Is the Messiah Without Using the New Testament?
How Paul Proclaimed Christ from the Hebrew Scriptures
Bruce Mitchell | Agapáō Allēlōn Ministries
A study through the Torah, the Prophets and the Writings, with Acts 13 and 17
A note on the texts. Scripture is quoted from the Complete Jewish Bible (CJB) unless marked NASB95 (New American Standard Bible, 1995) or JPS 1917 (the Jewish Publication Society’s 1917 translation of the Tanakh). The CJB and the JPS 1917 follow Hebrew verse numbering, which differs from most English Bibles in many psalms and in Isaiah 9. Where a quoted verse is numbered differently, both are given, Hebrew first: Psalm 22:17 (16). Other references follow English numbering.
Introduction: Take away your New Testament
Suppose you walked into a synagogue tomorrow, and someone met you at the door with one condition.
“You may tell me about Jesus. But you may not quote Matthew, or John, or Romans, or any other book of your New Testament. Show me from my Scriptures why I should believe he is the Messiah.”
Could you do it?

I have worshiped in Messianic synagogues, and I came away deeply blessed by their reverence for Scripture and their worship of Yahweh. The people in those rooms know the Tanakh and love it, and that makes the question personal for me.
Most of us who follow Jesus learned the gospel from a short list of New Testament verses. John 3:16. Romans 3:23 and 6:23. Romans 10:9. Ephesians 2:8–9. First Corinthians 15:3–4. Every one of them is true, and God has used them to bring many people to faith. Take them away, though, and many believers would struggle to make the case at all.
Paul worked without them. When he walked into the synagogue at Thessalonica, the letters that would later carry his name had not been written, and his listeners held one Bible: the Law, the Prophets and the Writings. Luke tells us what Paul did with it:
“According to his usual practice, Sha’ul went in; and on three Shabbats he gave them drashes from the Tanakh, explaining and proving that the Messiah had to suffer and rise again from the dead, and that ‘this Yeshua whom I am proclaiming to you is the Messiah.’” Acts 17:2–3
He had three Sabbaths, one book, and two claims to make, and the order of his argument matters. First Paul showed from the Scriptures what the Messiah had to be and do: suffer, and rise. Then he named Jesus as the one who fits. His listeners could weigh the first half of his case without trusting an apostle at all. They could open their own scrolls and check it.
That order gives this study its shape. We will close the New Testament for a while and ask the question Paul’s listeners asked: what had Moses, the Prophets and the Psalms already told Israel to expect? When the portrait is on the table, we will open the New Testament again and watch Paul set Jesus beside it.
In doing this we follow the apostles, who sent their hearers back to the older Scriptures. The New Testament remains the Word of God throughout.
The Scriptures and their translations
Three translations stand side by side in this study, and they do not always agree. Their disagreements are part of the conversation you would have across a synagogue table, so it helps to see them first.
The CJB was translated by David Stern, a Messianic Jewish scholar, and keeps Hebrew names and Jewish verse numbers. The NASB95 is a formal, word-for-word English translation from the evangelical world. The JPS 1917 was the standard English Bible of American synagogues for much of the twentieth century. Read together, they show where the Hebrew is plain and where honest readers have to make a choice.
Acts 17:3
CJB “explaining and proving that the Messiah had to suffer and rise again from the dead”
NASB95 “explaining and giving evidence that the Christ had to suffer and rise again from the dead”
Luke’s Greek says it was necessary (edei) for the Messiah to suffer. Paul argued from what Scripture required. “Messiah” and “Christ” translate the same Greek word, christos, which is the Septuagint’s word for the Hebrew māšîaḥ, “anointed one.”
Isaiah 7:14
CJB “the young woman will become pregnant, bear a son and name him ‘Immanu El [God is with us].’”
NASB95 “Behold, a virgin will be with child and bear a son, and she will call His name Immanuel.”
JPS 1917 “behold, the young woman shall conceive, and bear a son, and shall call his name Immanuel.”
The Hebrew word is ʿalmāh. Two of our three translations render it “young woman,” and the NASB95 offers “maiden” in its margin. The Jewish scholars who translated Isaiah into Greek before the time of Jesus chose parthenos, “virgin,” a choice the Isaiah section takes up.
Psalm 22:17 (16)
CJB “Dogs are all around me, a pack of villains closes in on me like a lion [at] my hands and feet.”
NASB95 “For dogs have surrounded me; A band of evildoers has encompassed me; They pierced my hands and my feet.”
JPS 1917 “For dogs have encompassed me; a company of evil-doers have inclosed me; like a lion, they are at my hands and my feet.”
The difference turns on one Hebrew letter. The standard Hebrew text reads kāʾărî, “like a lion.” The Septuagint, translated before Jesus was born, reads “they dug” or “pierced,” which assumes a Hebrew word ending in vav instead of yod (kāʾărû). The CJB prints “like a lion” and gives “They pierced my hands and feet” in its footnote, and the NASB95 does the reverse. The “pierced” reading stood in the Greek Bible before Jesus was born, so it did not begin with the church.
Isaiah 52:13
CJB “See how my servant will succeed! He will be raised up, exalted, highly honored!”
JPS 1917 “Behold, My servant shall prosper, He shall be exalted and lifted up, and shall be very high.”
The Hebrew verb yaśkîl means to act wisely and so to succeed. Isaiah’s song about the suffering Servant opens with his success.
Psalm 16:10
CJB “for you will not abandon me to Sh’ol, you will not let your faithful one see the Abyss.”
NASB95 “For You will not abandon my soul to Sheol; Nor will You allow Your Holy One to undergo decay.”
JPS 1917 “For Thou wilt not abandon my soul to the nether-world; Neither wilt Thou suffer Thy godly one to see the pit.”
The Hebrew šaḥat means “pit” or “ruin.” The Septuagint chose diaphthora, “decay,” and Paul used that word at Pisidian Antioch (Acts 13:35).
Daniel 9:26
CJB “Then, after the sixty-two weeks, Mashiach will be cut off and have nothing.”
NASB95 “Then after the sixty-two weeks the Messiah will be cut off and have nothing.”
JPS 1917 “And after the threescore and two weeks shall an anointed one be cut off, and be no more”
Here māšîaḥ stands without the article, so translators must choose between “the Messiah” and “an anointed one.” Every translation keeps the same order of events: the Anointed One is cut off, and then the city and the sanctuary are destroyed.
Start where Paul started: “According to the Scriptures”
The first believers in Jesus already had a Bible. Before a single Gospel was written, they owned the Scriptures Jesus himself read: the Torah, the Prophets and the Writings, which Jews call the Tanakh. When Paul wrote that the Messiah died for our sins and rose on the third day “according to the Scriptures” (1 Corinthians 15:3–4), those were the Scriptures he meant.
Acts shows Paul using them the same way in city after city:
- At Pisidian Antioch he traced Israel’s history to David, and from David to Jesus (Acts 13:14–41).
- At Thessalonica he reasoned from the Scriptures for three Sabbaths (Acts 17:1–3).
- At Corinth he reasoned in the synagogue every Sabbath and testified that the Messiah is Jesus (Acts 18:4–5).
- Apollos followed him there and debated in public, showing from the Scriptures that the Messiah is Jesus (Acts 18:28).
- In Rome, under guard, Paul spent a whole day persuading his Jewish visitors about Jesus from the Law of Moses and the Prophets (Acts 28:23).

Before King Agrippa, Paul summed up his ministry. He said he was “saying nothing but what both the prophets and Moshe said would happen,” namely, “that the Messiah would die, and that he, as the first to rise from the dead, would proclaim light to both the People and the Goyim” (Acts 26:22–23).
That was a bold thing to say while on trial for his faith.
A word about which Scriptures
Many synagogues Paul visited heard Scripture read in Greek. Across the Mediterranean, Jews used the translation we call the Septuagint, made in Alexandria and elsewhere in the centuries before Jesus. Paul’s quotations in Acts 13 follow the Greek wording where it differs from the Hebrew, and we will look at those places when we get there. In this study, “the Hebrew Scriptures” names the books Israel received, the Tanakh. Paul argued from that same collection whether he read it in Hebrew or heard it in Greek.
Acts tells us how Paul argued. It does not list every text he used. To rebuild his case, we have to go back to the Scriptures he called his own. So let us close the New Testament and ask his question: what had Moses, the Prophets and the Psalms told Israel to expect?
The Messiah promised in the Torah
Israel’s hope for a deliverer begins long before Isaiah. It starts in the first pages of Moses.
The offspring of the woman
In the garden, right after the first sin, God speaks to the serpent:
“I will put animosity between you and the woman, and between your descendant and her descendant; he will bruise your head, and you will bruise his heel.” Genesis 3:15
The Hebrew word for descendant, zeraʿ, can mean one child or a whole line of children. Moses keeps the pronoun singular: he will bruise your head. The verse promises a conflict, a victory and a cost. The serpent’s head is bruised, and the one who bruises it is wounded in the doing. When the Greek translators reached this verse, they used a masculine pronoun where Greek grammar expected a neuter one to agree with “seed,” as though they read it as one person.
We should not pour all of later theology into Genesis 3:15. But a line of hope starts here, and the rest of the Torah follows it.
The promise to Abraham
God calls Abram out of Ur and promises that all the families of the earth will be blessed through him (Genesis 12:3). After Mount Moriah, the promise narrows to Abraham’s offspring: “and by your descendants all the nations of the earth will be blessed” (Genesis 22:18).

From the start, the blessing God promised was aimed past Israel’s borders, at the nations, and it would reach them through Abraham’s line. Keep that thread in hand. It will matter when Paul leaves the synagogue and carries the message to Gentiles.
Judah and the ruler
On his deathbed, Jacob blesses his sons. To Judah he gives the scepter:
“The scepter will not pass from Y’hudah, nor the ruler’s staff from between his legs, until he comes to whom [obedience] belongs; and it is he whom the peoples will obey.” Genesis 49:10
Behind “he comes to whom [obedience] belongs” stands the Hebrew word Shiloh, and its meaning is debated. The ancient Aramaic Targums read it as a title of the Messiah, and so does a rabbinic discussion of the Messiah’s name in the Talmud (Sanhedrin 98b). The kings will come from Judah, and one king from that line will command the obedience of “the peoples,” the nations beyond Israel.
A prophet like Moses
Near the end of his life, Moses told Israel to expect someone else: “Adonai will raise up for you a prophet like me from among yourselves, from your own kinsmen.” And Israel would have to “pay attention to him” (Deuteronomy 18:15).
The closing chapter of Deuteronomy adds a sober note. Since then, it says, no prophet had arisen in Israel like Moses, whom the LORD knew face to face (Deuteronomy 34:10). The Torah ends with that promise still open.
By the last page of the Torah, Israel has been taught to look for an offspring who wins at a cost, a blessing that reaches the nations through Abraham, a king from Judah whom the peoples obey, and a prophet like Moses. The picture is unfinished, but the foundation is laid.
The Messiah must be a Davidic king
The promise to Judah takes a name in the days of David. David wanted to build God a house. Through the prophet Nathan, God answered that he would build David a house instead, a dynasty:
“He will build a house for my name, and I will establish his royal throne forever.” 2 Samuel 7:13
“Thus your house and your kingdom will be made secure forever before you; your throne will be set up forever.” 2 Samuel 7:16

God promised David an offspring, a kingdom and a throne, and the word forever comes back again and again. Solomon built the Temple, but Solomon died, and so did every king after him. In 586 BC the Babylonians burned Jerusalem, and the line of reigning kings came to an end. Israel was left holding the promise of a forever throne with no one on it. Psalm 89 is the prayer of a believer who felt that ache: God had sworn to David, and the crown lay in the dust (Psalm 89:35–39).
The royal Son
Psalm 2 puts the promise on stage. The kings of the earth set themselves against the LORD and against his anointed one (2:2). The Hebrew word is māšîaḥ, the word that comes into English as Messiah. Israel anointed its kings and priests with oil as a sign that God had chosen them. In Psalm 2 the Anointed is God’s own King, set on Zion, and God speaks to him directly:
“I will proclaim the decree: Adonai said to me, ‘You are my son; today I became your father.’ Ask of me, and I will make the nations your inheritance; the whole wide world will be your possession.” Psalm 2:7–8
This King is called God’s Son. His inheritance is the whole earth. The psalm closes by blessing everyone who takes refuge in him (2:12).
The extraordinary Davidic ruler
The New Testament returns to Psalm 110 often. David writes:
“Adonai says to my Lord, ‘Sit at my right hand, until I make your enemies your footstool.’” Psalm 110:1
“You are a cohen forever, to be compared with Malki-Tzedek.” Psalm 110:4
David is the king, and in Israel only God stood over him. Yet David speaks of a lord of his own whom God seats at His right hand. Then God swears that this ruler is also a priest forever. Under the Law, priests came from Aaron and kings from Judah, and when King Uzziah tried to burn incense in the Temple, God struck him (2 Chronicles 26:16–21). This ruler holds both offices, in an order older than Aaron: the order of Melchizedek, the priest-king of Salem who blessed Abraham (Genesis 14:18–20).
The Hebrew for “my Lord” is ʾădōnî, a word Israel also used for human masters, and Jewish readers have pointed that out for centuries. The question still stands: who is David’s master?
What kind of son of David can be David’s lord, sit beside God, rule the nations and serve as a priest forever? The Psalms leave the question hanging. The Prophets take it up.
Isaiah’s Messiah: King, Servant and Savior
If the Torah lays the foundation and the Psalms raise the walls, Isaiah furnishes the house. No prophet gives us more of the Messiah’s portrait, and no prophet holds more tension inside it.
The promised child (Isaiah 7:14)
This verse needs care. In the 730s BC, King Ahaz of Judah was terrified. The kings of Aram and Israel had joined forces against him. Isaiah offered Ahaz a sign, and Ahaz refused it. So the prophet turned from the king to the whole royal line: “Hear now, O house of David” (7:13). Then: “Adonai himself will give you people a sign: the young woman will become pregnant, bear a son and name him ‘Immanu El [God is with us].’”
Three things in the context deserve attention. First, the sign had a near horizon. Before the child was old enough to choose good over evil, the two kings Ahaz feared would be gone (7:16). Second, the Hebrew “you” in verse 14 is plural. The sign is addressed to the house of David, the dynasty Nathan’s promise had made permanent. Third, ʿalmāh describes a young woman of marriageable age. It is the word used of Rebekah at the well (Genesis 24:43) and of young Miriam at the Nile (Exodus 2:8). The Jewish scholars who translated Isaiah into Greek before the time of Jesus rendered it parthenos, “virgin.”
So we read Isaiah 7:14 first as a sign to Ahaz’s generation. And we notice that Isaiah does not let the child called “God is with us” stay small. The name returns in 8:8 and 8:10, and a chapter later a child is born who carries names no ordinary prince could bear.
The coming ruler (Isaiah 9:1–7; 8:23–9:6 in Hebrew)
Galilee of the nations, the region Assyria ravaged first, will see a great light. Then: “For a child is born to us, a son is given to us; dominion will rest on his shoulders,” and the CJB renders his names “Wonder of a Counselor, Mighty God, Father of Eternity, Prince of Peace” (9:5 (6)).
The second name is ʾēl gibbôr, Mighty God. A chapter later Isaiah uses the same title for the LORD himself, when the remnant of Jacob returns to El Gibbor (10:21). This child sits on David’s throne, his rule and his peace have no end, and the zeal of the LORD of hosts will accomplish it (9:6 (7)).
The Branch from Jesse (Isaiah 11:1–10)
David’s family tree is cut down to a stump, yet “a branch will emerge from the trunk of Yishai” (11:1). The Spirit of Adonai rests on him: wisdom, understanding, counsel, power, knowledge and the fear of the LORD (11:2). He judges the poor with justice, and his reign brings a peace that reaches even the animals. Then the nations come back into view. “On that day the root of Yishai” will stand as a banner for the peoples, and the Goyim will seek him out (11:10).

The Servant who brings justice to the nations (Isaiah 42:1–7)
Now a new title appears: the Servant of the LORD. God has put his Spirit on him, and he will bring justice to the nations quietly, without shouting in the streets (42:1–3). God tells him, “I, Adonai, called you righteously,” and makes him a covenant for the people and a light for the Goyim (42:6).
The Servant called Israel (Isaiah 49:1–7)
In the second Servant Song the Servant speaks for himself, and God’s words to him are startling:
“You are my servant, Isra’el, through whom I will show my glory.” Isaiah 49:3
Read only that verse and you might conclude that the Servant is simply the nation. Keep reading. The Servant says the LORD “formed me in the womb to be his servant, to bring Ya’akov back to him” (49:5). His mission is to Israel. Then God widens it: “I will also make you a light to the nations, so my salvation can spread to the ends of the earth” (49:6).

A servant who is called Israel and also restores Israel. Isaiah is describing one who embodies the nation and acts for it. Kings did that in Israel. When David went out against Goliath, he fought for the whole army. In the same way, the Servant can bear Israel’s name and still be one person acting on Israel’s behalf.
The suffering Servant (Isaiah 52:13–53:12)
The song opens with its ending: “See how my servant will succeed! He will be raised up, exalted, highly honored!” (52:13). The Hebrew pair behind “raised up” and “exalted” (rûm and nāśāʾ) is the pair Isaiah used for the LORD’s own throne, “high and lifted up,” in 6:1 and 57:15.
Then the song tells how he got there.
First he is rejected: “People despised and avoided him, a man of pains, well acquainted with illness” (53:3).
He suffers for others: “But he was wounded because of our crimes, crushed because of our sins; the disciplining that makes us whole fell on him, and by his bruises we are healed” (53:5).

He bears sin as an offering: “yet it pleased Adonai to crush him with illness, to see if he would present himself as a guilt offering” (53:10). The word is ʾāšām, the guilt offering of Leviticus 5.
He dies. He is cut off from the land of the living (53:8) and assigned a grave with the wicked (53:9).
And after death, he lives: “If he does, he will see his offspring; and he will prolong his days; and at his hand Adonai’s desire will be accomplished. After this ordeal, he will see satisfaction” (53:10–11). God gives him “a share with the great,” because he exposed himself to death “while actually bearing the sin of many and interceding for the offenders” (53:12).
Is the Servant Israel?
A Jewish friend will raise this question, and it deserves a serious answer. Since Rashi in the eleventh century, the main Jewish reading has identified the Servant of Isaiah 53 with the people of Israel, or the righteous within Israel, suffering among the nations. The reading is older than Rashi. Around AD 248, Origen reported a debate in which a Jewish scholar argued that the prophecy described the whole people as one individual, scattered and suffering (Contra Celsum 1.55). And Isaiah does call Israel God’s servant (41:8; 44:1).

Read the song itself, though, and the national reading strains at several points:
- The Servant suffers for “my people.” Isaiah 53:8 says he was stricken for the transgression of my people. The prophet speaks as one of Israel, and the Servant is distinct from them.
- The speakers confess their own guilt. The “we” of 53:4–6 admit that all of them went astray like sheep and that the LORD laid their iniquity on him. The Servant is the one they wronged.
- The Servant is innocent. He had done no violence, and there was no deceit in his mouth (53:9). Isaiah opens his book calling Israel a sinful nation weighed down with iniquity (1:4), and he says the exile came because of Israel’s own sins (42:24–25; 50:1).
- The Servant suffers willingly. He does not open his mouth, like a lamb led to slaughter (53:7), and he pours out his soul to death (53:12).
- The second song already drew the line: the Servant brings Jacob back to God (49:5–6).
Older Jewish voices read the song as messianic too. The Aramaic Targum of Isaiah opens it with “Behold, my servant the Messiah shall prosper” (52:13), though it then assigns much of the suffering to others. The Talmud gives the Messiah a name drawn from 53:4 (Sanhedrin 98b). Our Jewish friends deserve to hear that the messianic reading has deep roots in their own tradition.
So whoever Isaiah’s Servant is, we now know what kind of Messiah to look for. We are looking for one person who joins the King of Isaiah 9 and 11 to the Servant of Isaiah 42 through 53: rejected, suffering, offered for sin, dead and buried, then alive, exalted, and bringing God’s salvation to the ends of the earth.
Psalm 22: The sufferer who lives to praise
A psalm of David traces the same path from suffering to vindication, told from the inside.
It opens with a cry: “My God! My God! Why have you abandoned me?” (22:2 (1)). The sufferer is scorned by people who shake their heads and tell him to let the LORD rescue him, since God supposedly delights in him (22:8–9 (7–8)). He is poured out like water, his bones are out of joint, his strength is dried up like a broken pot, his tongue sticks to his palate, and God has laid him “in the dust of death” (22:15–16 (14–15)). His enemies close in: “Dogs are all around me, a pack of villains closes in on me like a lion [at] my hands and feet” (22:17 (16)). They divide his clothes and cast lots for them (22:19 (18)).
Then, in the middle of a verse, the psalm turns. The last word of 22:22 (21) in Hebrew is ʿănîtānî, “you answered me.” The man laid in the dust of death is standing in the assembly, declaring God’s name to his brothers (22:23 (22)). And the circle of praise keeps widening: “All the ends of the earth will remember and turn to Adonai” (22:28 (27)). The psalm closes with a people yet unborn hearing what God has done (22:31–32 (30–31)).

David wrote this psalm, and no event recorded in his life matches it. He was hunted and hated, but Scripture never shows him surrounded by men dividing his clothes while he watched. The psalm also follows the shape of Isaiah 53: suffering, the dust of death, praise in the assembly, and the nations turning to Israel’s God. A Jewish reader can trace that shape in his own Psalter.
On the textual question in 22:17 (16), see the translation notes near the beginning. Whichever reading you prefer, “like a lion at my hands and feet” or “they pierced my hands and feet,” the psalm describes a body under attack at the hands and the feet.
Does the Hebrew Bible anticipate resurrection?
Paul told the synagogue at Thessalonica that the Messiah had to suffer and rise. We have seen the suffering. Where would a Jewish listener find the rising?
The faithful one will not see the pit
In Psalm 16, David rejoices that even his body rests secure, “for you will not abandon me to Sh’ol, you will not let your faithful one see the Abyss” (16:10). The Hebrew ḥāsîd describes one who is faithful to God’s covenant love. The Greek translation rendered the last word “decay.” David died and was buried, and his body saw decay like every king after him. So the verse leaves a question: who is the faithful one who never saw decay?
The Servant after death
Go back to Isaiah 53:8–12. The Servant is cut off from the land of the living and buried. In the next breath, Isaiah says he will see his offspring and prolong his days, and God will give him a share with the great. A dead man does not prolong his days. Isaiah leaves the how unexplained and gives the sequence: death, then life, then exaltation.
The most complete ancient copy of Isaiah, the Great Isaiah Scroll from Qumran, copied in the second century BC, has one more word in 53:11: after his anguish, he will see light. Two other Qumran manuscripts and the Septuagint agree.

Resurrection in Daniel
Daniel states the hope outright:
“Many of those sleeping in the dust of the earth will awaken, some to everlasting life and some to everlasting shame and abhorrence.” Daniel 12:2
Bodily resurrection was part of Israel’s Scriptures before Jesus was born. Isaiah had promised it too: the dead would live, and those who dwell in the dust would wake and sing (Isaiah 26:19).
A word of restraint
No single verse here gives a complete doctrine of the Messiah’s resurrection. Paul’s case works cumulatively. Israel’s Scriptures supplied the pieces: God’s righteous one dies, God vindicates him, the faithful one does not stay in the pit, the dead will rise, and the Servant lives to see the fruit of his suffering. Put the pieces together, and Paul’s claim that the Messiah “had to suffer and rise again from the dead” reads like a summary of Isaiah.
Daniel: The Son of Man and the Anointed One
Daniel gives us two pictures that belong side by side.
One like a son of man (Daniel 7:9–14)
Daniel watches four beasts rise from the sea, the empires that would rule over Israel. Then thrones are set, and the Ancient One takes his seat in fire. Then:
“I kept watching the night visions, when I saw, coming with the clouds of heaven, someone like a son of man. He approached the Ancient One and was led into his presence. To him was given rulership, glory and a kingdom, so that all peoples, nations and languages should serve him. His rulership is an eternal rulership that will not pass away; and his kingdom is one that will never be destroyed.” Daniel 7:13–14

Look at what this figure receives: authority, glory, a kingdom, the service of every people, nation and language, and a rule that never ends. In the Hebrew Bible it is the LORD who rides on the clouds (Psalm 104:3; Isaiah 19:1). The Aramaic verb for “serve” in 7:14, pᵉlaḥ, is the verb Daniel uses for serving a god (3:12, 17, 18, 28). Yet this one comes “like a son of man,” a human figure.
Daniel 7 also gives the kingdom to “the holy ones of the Most High” (7:18, 27), and some readers take the son of man as a symbol of Israel. As with Isaiah’s Servant, the King and his people belong together. He receives the kingdom, and they share it.
Lay this beside what we have gathered: Judah’s scepter and the obedience of the peoples (Genesis 49:10), David’s forever throne (2 Samuel 7), the Son who inherits the nations (Psalm 2), David’s lord at God’s right hand (Psalm 110), the child called Mighty God whose government has no end (Isaiah 9), and the Branch whom the nations seek (Isaiah 11). The scattered pieces are forming one face. The promised deliverer belongs to David’s line, and his kingdom reaches far past anything David ruled.
The rabbis felt the tension. One passage in the Talmud sets Daniel 7:13, the son of man coming with the clouds, beside Zechariah 9:9, the king coming humble on a donkey. If Israel is worthy, it concludes, he comes with the clouds; if not, lowly on a donkey (Sanhedrin 98a).
The Anointed One cut off (Daniel 9:24–26)
Two chapters later, Daniel is praying over Jeremiah’s seventy years when Gabriel brings a larger number: seventy weeks, seventy sevens of years, decreed to finish transgression, atone for iniquity and bring in everlasting righteousness (9:24). From the decree to restore and rebuild Jerusalem “until an anointed prince comes” is seven weeks and sixty-two weeks (9:25). Then:
“Then, after the sixty-two weeks, Mashiach will be cut off and have nothing. The people of a prince yet to come will destroy the city and the sanctuary” Daniel 9:26

The verb yikkārēt, “cut off,” is common Hebrew for a death, often a violent one. The Anointed One dies having nothing, and after that the city and the sanctuary are destroyed.
Believers have worked out the arithmetic in more than one way, and Jewish and critical scholars have proposed other anointed figures, such as the high priest Onias III, murdered about 170 BC. Like many who read Scripture dispensationally, I see the sixty-ninth week ending at Messiah’s coming and the seventieth week (9:27) still ahead. One fact holds under every chronology. In Daniel’s sequence, the Anointed One is cut off before the city and the Second Temple are destroyed. Rome destroyed them in AD 70. Whoever the Messiah of Daniel 9 is, he had to come and die before that year.
Assemble the portrait before naming Jesus
Before we say his name, stop and gather what Israel’s Scriptures have told us. We are looking for someone who:
- comes from Israel as the offspring of Abraham, through whom the nations are blessed (Genesis 22:18)
- belongs to Judah and holds the scepter the peoples obey (Genesis 49:10)
- speaks for God as the prophet like Moses (Deuteronomy 18:15)
- is the son of David whose throne lasts forever (2 Samuel 7:13–16)
- is called God’s Son and inherits the nations (Psalm 2:7–8)
- sits at God’s right hand as king and priest forever (Psalm 110:1, 4)
- carries the names Mighty God and Prince of Peace (Isaiah 9:5 (6))
- has the Spirit of the LORD resting on him and judges with justice (Isaiah 11:1–5; 42:1)
- brings God’s salvation to the ends of the earth (Isaiah 49:6)
- is despised and rejected (Isaiah 53:3; Psalm 22:7–9 (6–8))
- suffers for the sins of others as a guilt offering (Isaiah 53:5, 10)
- dies, cut off and having nothing, before the Second Temple falls (Isaiah 53:8; Daniel 9:26)
- is vindicated after death and sees his offspring (Psalm 16:10; 22:22–23 (21–22); Isaiah 53:10–12)
- receives an everlasting kingdom from the Ancient One (Daniel 7:13–14)
That is a strange list for one person, joining a conquering king and a suffering servant in a single life. The rabbis themselves sometimes divided the portrait between two figures: a Messiah son of David who reigns, and a Messiah son of Joseph who is slain (Sukkah 52a).
So ask the question honestly, the way you would want your Jewish friend to ask it. In all of history, who fits this portrait?

Now we have earned the right to say his name.
Paul’s argument: “This Yeshua whom I am proclaiming to you is the Messiah”
Now open the New Testament again. Go back to Thessalonica, and Acts 17:2–3 reads differently after the road we have walked. Paul reasoned in three steps: Scripture tells us what the Messiah must do; Jesus has done these things; therefore Jesus is the Messiah Scripture promised.
Luke’s verbs show how he did it. Paul reasoned (dialegomai), explained (dianoigō, literally “opened”) and proved (paratithēmi, “set alongside”). He opened the texts, and then he set Jesus alongside them.
Acts 13: Paul at work
Acts 17 summarizes Paul’s method. Acts 13 shows it at length, in the synagogue at Pisidian Antioch, after the reading of the Law and the Prophets (13:15). Follow the sermon (13:16–41):
- Israel: God chose the fathers, brought them out of Egypt and gave them the land (13:17–19).
- David: God removed Saul and raised up David, a man after his own heart (13:22).
- Promise: from David’s descendants, as he promised, God brought Israel a Savior, Jesus (13:23).
- Rejection: the people of Jerusalem and their rulers did not recognize him, and by condemning him they fulfilled the words of the prophets read every Sabbath (13:27).
- Death: they asked Pilate to have him executed, then took him down from the tree and laid him in a tomb (13:28–29).
- Resurrection: God raised him from the dead, and for many days he was seen by witnesses (13:30–31).
- Fulfillment: what God promised the fathers, he has fulfilled for their children by raising Jesus (13:32–37).
At that last step Paul brings three texts together.
First, Psalm 2:7: “You are my son; today I became your father” (Psalm 2:7, quoted in Acts 13:33). The resurrection is God’s public declaration that Jesus is the royal Son.
Second, Isaiah 55:3: “I will give the holy and trustworthy things of David to you” (Acts 13:34). Here Paul follows the Greek. The Hebrew reads ḥasdê dāwid hanneʾĕmānîm, the faithful covenant love promised to David. The Septuagint renders it ta hosia Dauid ta pista, “the holy and trustworthy things of David.”
Third, Psalm 16:10: “You will not let your Holy One see decay” (Acts 13:35). Again Paul follows the Greek: diaphthora, “decay,” where the Hebrew has šaḥat, the pit.
Why pair those two texts? The Greek hosia in Isaiah 55:3 shares its root with hosios, “Holy One,” in Psalm 16:10. Paul links the passages by their shared word, a method the rabbis called gezerah shavah, “equal decree.” The holy things promised to David come through the Holy One who does not see decay. Then Paul spells out the logic: David served God’s purpose in his own generation, died and saw decay, and the one God raised did not (13:36–37). A trained Pharisee is reasoning the way his teachers taught him.
Then the sermon turns to grace:
“Therefore, brothers, let it be known to you that through this man is proclaimed forgiveness of sins!” Acts 13:38
Paul adds that “God clears everyone who puts his trust in this man” of all the things the Torah of Moses could not clear them of (13:39).
He closes with a warning from Habakkuk 1:5: “You mockers! Look, and marvel, and die!” (13:41). Here too he follows the Greek: where the Hebrew says “Look among the nations,” the Septuagint reads “Look, you scoffers.” The next Sabbath almost the whole city gathered. When some in the synagogue opposed them, Paul and Barnabas turned to the Gentiles with Isaiah’s second Servant Song on their lips: “I have set you as a light for the Goyim, to be for deliverance to the ends of the earth” (13:47, quoting Isaiah 49:6).
The struggle
Several things make this hard. The portrait is assembled from many places, and Isaiah never wrote the sentence “The Messiah will die and rise.” The texts point toward it, and the case depends on seeing how they fit together. A skeptic can always isolate one verse and argue for another reading. Isaiah 7:14 had a meaning for Ahaz, and Psalm 22 was David’s prayer before it was anyone else’s. Daniel’s numbers have more than one honest solution too. An honest case admits all of this.
Our habits make it harder. Many of us learned messianic prophecy as a list of predictions and fulfillments, verse against verse, scored like a quiz. A Jewish friend who knows the context will spot a pulled verse in seconds. Proof-texting fails to persuade, and it tells our friend we have not taken his Scriptures seriously.
The deepest difficulty is the one Trypho raises in Justin Martyr’s Dialogue, written around AD 155. The Scriptures plainly say the Messiah must suffer, Trypho admits. A crucified Messiah, a man hung on a tree under the Law’s curse, is more than he can accept (Dialogue with Trypho 89–90). The cross offends before it persuades.
So the struggle is real, and facts alone do not open anyone’s eyes. Paul reasoned in Thessalonica, and some were persuaded (Acts 17:4). Others gathered a mob (17:5).
Grace
Grace enters this story through Israel. God made his promises to Abraham, Judah and David before any Gentile nation knew his name. He kept them alive in Israel’s Scriptures for centuries, through exile and silence. Then he fulfilled them in a son of David, born a Jew, who opened the scroll of Isaiah in the synagogue at Nazareth (Luke 4:16–21).
And the blessing went where Genesis 22:18 said it would go: to the nations. I am an adopted son of the Creator, welcomed into a promise that was never mine by birth. Israel remains God’s chosen people (Romans 11:28–29), and I am glad to be brought in.
Look again at the Servant in Isaiah 53. He bears the sins of people who despised him, while they still think God is punishing him. “By his bruises we are healed.” The healing comes as a gift to people who had turned away.
Paul’s sermon in Acts 13 lands in the same place: forgiveness proclaimed through this man, and everyone who trusts him cleared of what the Law of Moses could never clear. It is the grace Paul would later describe to the believers at Ephesus. By grace you have been saved through faith, the gift of God, so that no one can boast (Ephesians 2:8–9).
The God who made the promises kept them.
Could you actually do it?
Go back to the table. Your Jewish friend says, “Don’t quote the New Testament to prove the New Testament.” How do you answer?
Calmly. You are a guest in his Scriptures, and they are God’s Word to you both. Leave the isolated verses in your pocket and walk the road the texts walk: Genesis, then David, then the Psalms, then Isaiah, then Daniel.
Ask more than you assert. Let him read the passages aloud and tell you what he sees. Questions like these put the weight on the text:
- Who is the king God promised would reign on David’s throne forever, and where is he now?
- Who is David’s lord, seated at God’s right hand and a priest forever?
- In Isaiah 53, who are the “we,” and who is the one who suffers for “my people”?
- Why does the Servant who is called Israel bring Jacob back to God?
- How does the Servant see his offspring after he is cut off from the land of the living?
- Why does Daniel’s Anointed One have to die before the Second Temple is destroyed?
- Why does God’s salvation reach the ends of the earth?
- What person in history brings these lines together?
Then tell him about Jesus of Nazareth. Tell him the story Paul told at Pisidian Antioch, and invite him to check it against the scrolls.
Some conversations will end without agreement. I have watched too many believers win the fight and lose the soul. Open the Scriptures, set Jesus beside them, and love your friend the whole way through. Leave the persuading to the Spirit.
Voices across the centuries
Followers of Jesus have walked this road for two thousand years, and Jewish readers have walked beside them, often agreeing about the texts while disagreeing about the person.
The early church
Justin Martyr’s Dialogue with Trypho (about AD 155 to 160) is a long conversation with a Jewish teacher built almost entirely on the Hebrew Scriptures, including Isaiah 53, Psalm 22 and Daniel 7. At one point Trypho concedes, “It is quite clear, indeed, that the Scriptures announce that Christ had to suffer” (ch. 89). His objection was the cross. Origen, around AD 248, recorded the national reading of Isaiah 53 and answered from the text: if the people are the subject, how can the man be led to death because of the iniquities of the people of God, unless he is someone other than that people (Contra Celsum 1.55)? Augustine summed up the two testaments in a line preachers still quote: the New is concealed in the Old, and the Old is revealed in the New (Questions on the Heptateuch 2.73).
The Reformation
Martin Luther, in his 1523 preface to the Old Testament, warned against despising these books, because in them believers find “the swaddling cloths and the manger in which Christ lies”. John Calvin, commenting on John 5:39, wrote that “we ought to read the Scriptures with the express design of finding Christ in them.”
Contemporary scholars
Walter Kaiser traced one promise-plan running from Genesis 3:15 to the Messiah (The Messiah in the Old Testament, 1995). Michael Rydelnik of Moody Bible Institute argues that the Hebrew Bible was written to be read messianically from the start (The Messianic Hope, 2010). Darrell Bock of Dallas Theological Seminary and Mitch Glaser gathered evangelical and Messianic Jewish scholars around the single question of Isaiah 53 (The Gospel According to Isaiah 53, 2012). Alfred Edersheim, a nineteenth-century Jewish believer in Jesus, counted 456 Old Testament passages that ancient rabbinic writings applied to the Messiah. He also argued that a likeness is recognized by the way its features combine into a unity (The Life and Times of Jesus the Messiah, 1883, 1:160 and Appendix IX).
Messianic Jewish voices
Arnold Fruchtenbaum, a Jewish believer and the founder of Ariel Ministries, walks through the Law, the Prophets and the Writings in their first-century Jewish order to show how the portrait of the Messiah builds (Messianic Christology, 1998). His reading of Isaiah 7 as a word to Ahaz and a separate word to the house of David shapes the approach above. Fruchtenbaum writes as a dispensationalist, and readers from other traditions will weigh his framework differently. David Stern, translator of the CJB, wrote his Jewish New Testament Commentary (1992) to read the apostles from inside their Jewish world.
Jewish interpreters
The Aramaic Targum of Isaiah, which reached its final form by about the fifth century AD, opens the fourth Servant Song with “Behold, my servant the Messiah shall prosper” (52:13). The Babylonian Talmud names the Messiah from Isaiah 53:4 (Sanhedrin 98b). Rashi (1040–1105) read the Servant as Jacob, the righteous among Israel. Christ-followers who want to speak into this conversation should first learn it.
Theological significance
One God wrote one story. The promise spoken in Eden, narrowed to Abraham, Judah and David, and deepened in Isaiah and Daniel, comes to rest in one Person. The Old Testament is the ground the New stands on, and the New is the fulfillment the Old was waiting for.
Paul’s word in Acts 17:3 is “had to.” The Messiah’s suffering belonged to the plan from the beginning. Isaiah 53 makes it an offering for sin, and Daniel 9 sets it inside God’s timetable. God marked the road to Golgotha in Israel’s Scriptures centuries before anyone walked it.
God kept his promises to Abraham and David across more than a thousand years. He will keep his word to Israel and to the nations. The portrait of Daniel 7 is not yet complete; not every nation serves the Son of Man today. The Scriptures that foretold his suffering also promise his kingdom, and the first half of the promise is our assurance of the second.
Reflection questions
- If someone took away your favorite New Testament verses, which Old Testament passages could you open to explain who the Messiah is?
- Paul showed first what the Messiah must do, and only then named Jesus. Why does that order matter when you talk with someone who does not yet trust the New Testament?
- The promise to Abraham was aimed at the nations from the start (Genesis 22:18). How does that change the way you see your own place in God’s story?
- In Isaiah 53 the people misjudged the Servant, thinking God was punishing him. Where have you misjudged suffering, in yourself or in someone else?
- How would you answer a friend who says the Servant of Isaiah 53 is the nation of Israel? Which verses would you ask him to read with you?
- Psalm 22 moves from “Why have you abandoned me?” to praise in the assembly. What would it look like to pray that psalm honestly in your own season of suffering?
- Daniel 9:26 places the Anointed One’s death before the destruction of the Second Temple. Why does a promise tied to history strengthen the case?
- Who in your life would welcome a calm conversation built on questions? What first question could you ask?
Heartbeat sentence
Israel’s own Scriptures foretold a Messiah who would suffer, rise and bring salvation to the nations, and Jesus of Nazareth is the one who fits that portrait.
Cross references
- Paul’s method: Acts 13:14–48; 17:1–4; 18:4–5, 28; 26:22–23; 28:23; 1 Corinthians 15:3–4
- Jesus and the Scriptures: Luke 4:16–21; 24:25–27, 44–47; John 5:39–47
- The Torah: Genesis 3:15; 12:1–3; 22:15–18; 49:8–12; Numbers 24:17; Deuteronomy 18:15–19; 34:10–12
- David’s throne: 2 Samuel 7:12–16; Psalms 2; 89:19–37; 110; 132:11–12
- Isaiah: 7:10–16; 8:8–10; 9:1–7; 10:21; 11:1–10; 42:1–9; 49:1–13; 50:4–9; 52:13–53:12; 55:3–5; 61:1–3
- Suffering and vindication in the Psalms: Psalms 16:8–11; 22; 69:20–21; 118:22–23
- Resurrection: Isaiah 26:19; Daniel 12:2–3; Hosea 6:2
- Daniel: 7:9–14, 18, 27; 9:24–27
- Other prophets: Micah 5:2; Zechariah 9:9; 12:10; 13:7
- Fulfillment and grace: Romans 1:1–4; 11:25–29; 15:8–12; Galatians 3:8, 16; Ephesians 2:8–13; 1 Peter 1:10–12
Personal reflection
Hermeneutics was one of my favorite classes at Dallas Theological Seminary, and I still go back to the Hebrew and Greek texts. Walking these passages again, I am struck by how patient God is. He spoke a promise in Eden and added to it for more than a thousand years, through Abraham, Judah, David, Isaiah and Daniel, before he showed Israel the face that belonged to it.
I am an adopted son in that story, a Gentile grafted into promises made to Israel. When I read Isaiah 53, I belong among the “we.” All of us went astray. He carried it anyway.
Conclusion: The promise kept
The apostles proclaimed something that sounded glorious to some in the synagogue and outrageous to others: the God who made the promises had acted in history to keep them. The offspring of the woman had come. The son of David had been rejected, had suffered and died as a guilt offering, and God had raised him from the dead. The blessing of Abraham was running out to the nations, as Genesis said it would.
That is why Paul could stand in Thessalonica for three Sabbaths with only the Tanakh in front of him, “explaining and proving that the Messiah had to suffer and rise again from the dead,” and then say, “this Yeshua whom I am proclaiming to you is the Messiah” (Acts 17:3).
Here is the challenge I leave with you. Take away Romans. Take away Galatians. Take away John. Take away every verse you normally use when you explain the gospel. Could you still open the Scriptures Israel possessed and show someone why the Messiah must suffer, why he must be vindicated, why salvation must reach the nations, and why Jesus of Nazareth fits that portrait?
Paul could.

Those of us who proclaim Paul’s gospel can learn to do the same. Start with Isaiah 53 this week. Read it slowly. Ask who the “we” are, and who the one is who suffers for them. Then read it again with a friend.
Grace. Always grace.
With love, prayer, and expectancy,
Bruce Mitchell
Agapao Allelon Ministries
A voice of love & grace—always grace
Bruce@allelon.us
allelon.us
@AAllelon on X
Substack
“Most important of all, continue to show deep love for each other, for love conceals a multitude of sins.” —1 Peter 4:8
Feel free to reply below, subscribe for more, or reach out—I’d love to pray with you
Scripture notices. Scripture quotations marked CJB are taken from the Complete Jewish Bible, copyright © 1998 by David H. Stern. All rights reserved. Scripture quotations marked NASB95 are taken from the (NASB®) New American Standard Bible®, copyright © 1960, 1971, 1977, 1995 by The Lockman Foundation. Used by permission. All rights reserved. lockman.org. Quotations marked JPS 1917 are from The Holy Scriptures According to the Masoretic Text (Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society of America, 1917), in the public domain.


